With rescheduling the party, the Santa (another board member's father) lined up for the 11th was unable to help out the 18th. After exhausting all other revenues (the group president and I were trying to find anyone Santa-like we could think of), I finally had to call in the final reserve. Rich filled in for us as Santa. Not the most Santa-like person we could find but he did a great job! Luckily Santa sits the whole time so the kids didn't have to crane their necks to see a 6'5" Santa face.
The buddy had fun at the party but was nervous the entire time by Santa in the corner. Nevermind that I had told the kids that it was Papa in the costume. Once he put the costume on, he became Santa and they wanted nothing to do with him!
Jake actually came along to the party to help watch the kids! I believe this was his dad's stipulation in playing Santa as he knows that it annoys me that Jake won't come to these events. Here is a picture of Carter and Jacob while they were standing in the corner watching Santa. Jake was trying to convince Carter to go sit on Santa's lap. You can see how thrilled Carter looks at the idea.
Ellie went and sat on his lap but not without a fair amount of bribery.

Jake finally just picked up Carter and stood by Santa for a quick picture.
Jake finally just picked up Carter and stood by Santa for a quick picture.
We decided to pose with Santa to see if that would help the kids take a family picture. Carter is standing behind the picture taker screaming his head off at us. Where is Ava? She wouldn't pass a certain point in the room as it took her too close to Santa. She stayed by the craft and cookie tables and only sat on the chairs furthest from Santa. There was no way she was getting anywhere near there!
So the kids still don't really like Santa. Jake left the party (we might have "misplaced" Ava for a few minutes, in which he got extremely stressed out and decided he was done sitting there trying to watch everyone. She was just sitting at the craft table making another ornament but we didn't see her and Jake doesn't do stressful situations very well) and so Rich and I drove back together. As soon as I got home, Ava and Carter converged on me wondering if Papa was back to normal. They didn't like him as Santa! We shall see what next year's attitude about Santa will be....